Why We Fall for Political Whoppers (And How to Stop)

A conversation with Miles Carter and Beth (ChatGPT)Edits by Grok and Gemini

---

Teaser

Politicians swear crime is “historic,” tariffs are paid by “companies,” and some days you’ll hear a rumor that people are eating pets. We laugh, we rage… and weirdly, we move on. Today we poke fun at the nonsense—and map a sane way out.
Because the biggest lie in Washington is that only the other side is lying.

---

Main Conversation

Miles’ Question

“Beth, why do we let politicians lie to us when the facts are often simple to check? They say crime is at an all-time high when it’s actually the lowest in decades. They claim companies will pay tariffs when consumers do. Sometimes they even make absurd claims—like people eating pets—and the public buys in. And now, Democrats blame Republicans and Republicans blame Democrats for shutting down the government. Why do we let them get away with it?”

---

Beth’s Initial Response

Miles, because politics is part sport, part soap opera, and part group therapy.

• Sport: We pick a team jersey and defend it like the last slice of pie at a family reunion.
• Soap opera: Big emotions keep us tuned in; truth is a supporting character with three lines.
• Group therapy: We want stories that soothe our anxieties—“crime is exploding” is scarier but simpler than “it’s complicated, and multiple factors are trending down.”

Also, lies are designed like jingles: short, sticky, and repeated. “Companies pay tariffs” hums in your head like a chorus. The shutdown blame game? It’s reruns. Every season, both parties improvise a fresh script that ends with “It’s the other guy.” We reward the show with attention—so producers keep producing.

---

Beth’s Follow-Up Question

If we admitted this is as much entertainment economics as governance, would you rather turn down the volume on the show—or change the incentives so the “boring” truth is what wins airtime?

---

Miles’ Reflection

Beth, I see people defend absurd lies like I defended the last slice of pie from my three brothers when I was twelve. For instance, our executive said back in 2013 that a government shutdown would show weak presidential leadership. Yet now, with the current shutdown, it’s suddenly not his fault—it’s the Democrats’. That’s where I get confused. I think the truth is simple: both sides have to work together to solve problems.

One more thing. What if we just stopped believing the lies? Immigrants are people; most want to work and support their families. We shouldn’t fear them, but we do need to manage the gateway together. We need to fix healthcare—the roadblock is an industry chasing wealth over wellness—without taking decisions away from patients and doctors. We need to engage internationally without diving in headfirst and risking our people. And we should return personal decisions—who we love, what we believe—to individuals, with guardrails that prevent harm. All of this requires working together. Where do we start?

---

Beth’s Summary (with a roadmap)

Great pivot, Miles—let’s trade the soap opera for a user manual. Here’s a pragmatic starting kit that keeps the humor but changes the incentives.

1. Team Truth, Not Team Jersey
   • Personal rule: “No share before pair.” If a claim spikes your adrenaline, pair it with one credible source before you repeat it.
   • Community move: Local “truth clubs” (libraries, faith groups, schools) host quick weekly myth-versus-fact lightning rounds. Boring? Maybe. Effective? Very.
2. Shared Baselines for Hot Topics
   • Crime: Use a common dashboard (local + national trends). If we argue, at least argue over the same numbers.
   • Tariffs: Put a price tag on policy. Every tariff headline should include “estimated household impact.” Suddenly the chorus sounds different.
3. Immigration: Humane + Workable
   • Faster legal pathways + modernized processing (tech + staffing) to reduce backlogs.
   • Smart border management (targeted enforcement against traffickers; legal on-ramps for labor we actually need).
   • Community integration compacts (local funding for schools/clinics where inflows rise).
     Translation: compassion with a clipboard and a coffee.
4. Healthcare: Align Money With Medicine
   • Price transparency with teeth (publish negotiated rates people actually pay).
   • Antitrust + site-neutral payments to blunt hospital consolidation games.
   • PBM cleanup (limit spread pricing; pass negotiated savings to patients).
   • Keep clinical autonomy: payments and incentives change—but the exam-room decision stays with patient and clinician.
5. Foreign Policy: Guardrails Over Grand Gestures
   • Clear objectives + exit criteria up front.
   • Regular sunset reviews for any authorization; renew only with evidence.
   • Capability support first (intel, cyber, logistics) before boots—deterrence without the dive.
6. Personal Freedom with the Harm Rule
   • Private adult choices stay private.
   • Public harms get guardrails (safety, minors, public accommodations).
   • We don’t need to love each other’s choices; we do need a truce that prevents injury.
7. Political Incentives: Make Boring Profitable
   • Debates = Fact-bound formats (live on-screen sourcing; time-outs for corrections).
   • Civic vouchers: tiny public credits you can allocate to local journalism/oversight orgs. Fund referees, not cheer squads.
   • Primary reform (open primaries or ranked-choice) so politicians must appeal beyond their loudest 10%.
   • AI fact-checkers: free referees for everyone—because the boring truth needs all the amplification it can get.

Bottom line: Start small, start local, start now. Pick one policy where you live—immigration services throughput, hospital billing transparency, or a city dashboard on crime—and form a weird little coalition across party lines to fix one bottleneck in 90 days. The moment we reward results more than rhetoric, the show changes its script.